The ex-captain of Sheffield United’s women’s team testified at an inquest, suggesting that Maddy Cusack’s girlfriend relocating was a significant factor in her mental health deterioration. Testimony revealed that Cusack’s family lodged a complaint against the team’s head coach, Jonathan Morgan, citing issues related to her association with him. Cusack was discovered unresponsive at her residence in Horsley, Derbyshire, by her father, leading to her passing on September 20, 2023.
During the inquest, Sophie Barker, the former team captain, emphasized the impact of Cusack’s girlfriend, Grace Riglar, moving away. Barker highlighted that Cusack struggled emotionally upon learning of Riglar’s departure to another football club, feeling abandoned. Barker reassured Cusack that the move did not signify a breakup but noted the toll it took on her mental well-being.
Contrary to suggestions that Morgan’s conduct and lack of club support were primary contributors to Cusack’s mental decline, Barker maintained that Riglar’s departure played a pivotal role. Cusack expressed concerns about Morgan based on prior negative interactions at a previous club. Despite reservations, Cusack was willing to give Morgan another chance but refrained from discussing any issues with Barker.
Additional insights from the inquest revealed Cusack’s perception of Morgan engaging in manipulative behavior and making disparaging remarks about her. Barker observed a noticeable change in Cusack’s demeanor in mid-2023, characterized by withdrawal and reduced engagement with the team. The inquest also highlighted a distressing incident where Cusack broke down over a training ground mix-up, indicating emotional distress.
The inquest heard conflicting views on Cusack’s absence from the starting line-up, with Carr, the head physiotherapist, suggesting it was in Cusack’s best interest due to a prior injury. Despite the ongoing inquiry, Carr indicated that Cusack did not voice complaints about Morgan during the summer of 2023.
The proceedings are ongoing, shedding light on the complex circumstances surrounding Cusack’s mental health struggles and the factors contributing to her tragic passing.
For immediate support, individuals can contact Samaritans for assistance or visit their website.

